Skip to main content

Mortgage Loan Denied

Forgive me, as I write this post through a cake fueled haze. I’m an emotional eater. And today, well it has been an emotional rollercoaster. Where to begin? Today I was informed via email that my HSBC mortgage loan application was being denied. According to my loan officer, she was appealing that decision. Several minutes later I received a convoluted email about an unreimbursed employment expense on my 2012 tax return which would significantly decrease my income for 2012. What? I called the loan officer for an explanation.

In 2010, I attended graduate school, trying to advance my career in my field. I worked fulltime and was on a three year part-time graduate school track.  I paid for the first year of school mostly out of my own savings and bi-weekly paychecks. It was a struggle. In the second year of grad school, I applied for and received a federal student loan. However the loan did not completely cover the full cost of my tuition and last year I spent $16,000 of my own hard earned cash to pay for a year’s worth of classes. Like I said, it was a struggle but I was determined to complete my degree.  The underwriter deducted this expense from my gross annual income, and responded that I wouldn’t be able to make the monthly payments on the loan. Now it appeared to me, that HSBC was penalizing me for being too efficient, too careful with money. I paid off a debt and it’s being used against me? I explained to the loan officer that the $16,000 was part of a onetime tuition payment and I’m no longer in school after graduating earlier this year and therefore does not have that expense this year. Her response was, it doesn’t matter and that I should send an email to her explaining what I had stated on the telephone, though she doubts that the loan will be approve. She will forward my response to the underwriter. It goes without saying, but I was extremely angry about this and immediately wanted to close my current account with HSBC.  Where do I go from here? I finally found a coop and it appeared that it was slipping through my fingers.
I called my attorney, and he was very supportive. He stated that it was a BS excuse and the truth was that HSBC did not or does not want to approve loans for coops; therefore they find many excuses to deny the loan. He reminded me that they have had the application for almost 90 days before coming to this conclusion. He asked me if I wanted to continue with the property and I was ecstatic that there were still options available to me. He gave me the contact information for another mortgage loan company and I immediately contacted the loan officer. I explained the situation to him and now he is reviewing my papers.
I called my realtor and she reiterated what the attorney said. HSBC needed a reason to deny me that loan because I’m buying a cooperative and not a house.
I’m still feeling a bit raw, right now. Still on edge. Still angry. I have wasted three months with a bank, who tried every reason possible to deny me a home loan. It’s hard not to take it personally and it’s easy to blame the underwriter for the difficulty. But I put the blame squarely on HSBC. Their mortgage loan process leaves a lot to be desired.
One of my coworker is going to closing on her 4th home later this month. This coworker has had a property that was foreclosed several years ago and a large amount of student loan debt, yet she was approved for a mortgage. Me, I have no liens, no foreclosures, a comparatively small student loan, yet I get penalize for paying my bills. I don’t get it.
If anyone else has had a similar experience, please share.  
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I found another house

At the end of July, I thought that I had found my dream home. I made an offer. The seller countered. Then I accepted the seller’s counter offer.   I was already trying to schedule the home inspection when my realtor, Robert, texted me that the seller wanted to hold off. Well, according to Robert, the seller decided to sell the home to his neighbor’s friend. I was disappointed but then oddly felt relief. As much as I like the home and the area, I was a little worried that the location was a little too isolated. It was close to buses but far away from the train. I was concerned about how I would get to and from work. Robert would still make his commission as he was acting as both the buyer and seller’s agent. Everyone was happy except for me. I then called another former realtor, Louis, and we began looking at properties.   We went to an open house on a quiet street, a few blocks away from a subway station and a block from a bus, that was listed below market value. There w...
Post a Comment
Read more

Commitment Letter and Appraisal

Today, I got news that I've been waiting for for several months.  I finally got a mortgage commitment letter!  When I got the congratulatory email today there was this sense of I don't know, joy and sadness at the same time. I wanted to scream from the rooftop and then I wanted to cry. I'm excited but past experience has made me extremely cautious. I have always said that I don't want to focus on the negative but there is this part of me that is feeling uncertain and doubtful. A lot has happened over the last several months and it would be heartbreaking to get this far and have to be disappointed. On the other hand, it appears that everything is coming together. Yeah, finally some good news.  We have a tentative closing date of October 1, 2013. But before we get to closing I will need to be interviewed by the coop board. Thankfully I had completed my coop application package in June and the only missing document was the commitment letter, which I imm...
Post a Comment
Read more

We're in Contract

Last week we completed the home inspection. There were a few concerns such as a leaking faucet and fallen off cabinet doors but nothing that would impede us going forward with the deal. The house appeared to be in good working condition though it is in desperate need of deep cleaning.   My realtor has taken to calling this house a “hot property”, as there continues to be a lot of interest and offers. He was concerned that someone else could swoop in and make a higher offer than mine.   Apparently, there was a prior offer to mine and that deal fell apart after the inspection when the “greedy buyer” wanted to renegotiate the price.   I made my offer at the right time. Also, it was about $10,000 more than the prior offer. My realtor was eager for us to go to contract.   Present at the inspection were myself, my realtor, the inspection, the homeowner and the listing agent. I had asked my mom to come along as well for moral support. Mom did not see the home prior to...
Post a Comment
Read more